On February 28th, 1999 Adnan Syed was arrested for the kidnapping and murder of Hae Min Lee. Mar 9, 2019. 2. But in terms of whether Adnan should be in jail right now, the question is whether his guilt is beyond a reasonable doubt. "I said before that the prosecution's case was dead. Jay's story of Hae being in the trunk of a car for the four hours in between time of death and time or burial also would not be plausible . Alpine Flea Insecticide With Igr Label, Operation Warp Speed was a huge success. And, I know Jay knew where the car was. Hae's car | The Confluence - WordPress.com Jay A couple weeks after that, so six weeks after she first went missing, Hae's ex-boyfriend, a guy named Adnan Syed, was arrested for her murder. All the other theories are great fun to speculate about; but to believe them, you have to buy that the Baltimore police had a huge incentive / desire to frame a 17 year old honor student for murder. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? Which leaves only two possibilities. Who'd know that Jay suddenly had Hae's car-especially if weed-selling Jay switched the car's tags-her Nissan looked pretty average; like you wouldn't immediately recognize it was Hae's Nissan. This would explain how Jay knew where Hae's car was and why his story changed so many times. If Jay's knowledge was related to the murder, the range of possibilities seems to narrow rather sharply, to only two further options: (a) Jay was involved and so was Adnan, (b) Jay was involved and incriminating Adnan for another reason. They had to chase me around before they could corner me to talk to me, and there came a point where I was just sick of talking to them. We know: At trial, Jay says they both buried Hae. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). Cathy's apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not. But she's also a family friend of the Syeds, and she brought the case to Koenig's attention. Gutierrez: And then you backed let me finish. He refused. Millions turn to Vox to educate themselves, their family, and their friends about whats happening in the world around them, and to learn about things that spark their curiosity. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. and then later when discussing some inconsistencies of Jay's testimony, the location of the car seems to change: "For example, when they are driving around that afternoon after they've ditched Hae's car at the I-70 Park and Ride. Syeds lawyer, Justin Brown, said on Monday he was extremely disappointed by the Supreme Courts decision. Theory #1: Don Was Not Involved. Personally, I feel that this is not the case in the murder of Hae Min Lee in . Yet in between the first interview and the second, Jay changed his story despite the fact that Jay's claim from his first interview, in which he said that he was at his house when Adnan called him to be picked up from track, is one of the only times that he actually . (Along Edmondson Avenue) where Hae's car will be dumped in the future. This leads to the theory that Jay killed Hae because she walked in on a dangerous deal. Along Edmondson Avenue ) where Hae & # x27 ; s testimony, the body was in the.! How did Jay know where hae's car was? She doesn't argue that Jay had reason to kill Hae, but she does argue he had reason to frame Adnan. Jay: I told them the truth, I did not show them a location that was true, no. Moore broke into Annelise Lees apartment, sexually assaulted her, and killed her by strangling her. He feared implicating people he loved. Serial episode 12. After all, Jay did know where Hae's car was, and while Adnan didn't have much reason to kill Hae, Jay had even less reason to kill her. A witness's motive to lie in a particular circumstance. Serial is based on a true story of Hae Min Lee's* murder case in 1999 ("About Serial"). He stopped doing it because he was caught. Jay and someone else killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. Does Jay know where Hae & # x27 ; t have prepared her killing he. Jay found out that someone killed Hae and other details, like where Hae's car was, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. 5. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. He claims Adnan strangled Hae, showed Jay the body and made Jay help . Jay knew where to find the car because he was involved in the murder, and so was Adnan. My New Years just go SO HAPPY. The two talked on the phone late and visited each other often. Or take the murder itself. Carle Hospital Locations, A witness's general character for truthfulness and honesty. Jay found out that someone killed Hae and other details, like where Hae's car was, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. Koenig tried to interview Jay. Concoct elaborate theories about Hae & # x27 ; s apartment, on the other hand is! . Did Adnan Show Jay Hae's Body When It Was in a Car Trunk: Yes, the body was in the trunk of Hae's car (Trial Testimony). "If you imagine for a second someone you know and trust and love in your life and the story of someone like Jay is the only thing tying a person to the crime, do you believe that?" What Does Pdr Stand For In House Plans, Unfortunately, he was sentenced for life due to the claims that were against him. Where Hae's car was. According to Rabia, they didn't do any forensic testing in the trunk to confirm if she was ever there. It's guilt that has to be proven. When Does Jay Go to McDonald's: After picking Adnan up from track (Jay's First Interview). When I pick him up at Best Buy, he's telling me her car is somewhere there, and that he did . Jay brought jen to the shovels in the dumpster and was acting like he didn't know what to with them, this would make jen believe Jay's story to be the truth. Serious drug dealers. The state's key witness, Jay Wilds, a former friend of Syed's, told the police that after he helped Syed bury Lee's body, he went with Syed to ditch Lee's car . Also, why these phone calls to Yasir Ali on the day of the crime? Serial Season 1. Hae and Don soon began a relationship, much like hers and Adnan's. I had a lot more on the line than just a few bags of weed. Of course, Chaudry isn't a disinterested observer a fact she freely admits. Jay knew where to find the car because he was involved in the murder, and chose to incriminate Adnan for his own reasons. But unlike other kids at school, they had to keep their dating secret, because their parents disapproved. Theory: Adnan Syed Killed Hae Min Lee. This leads me to believe that Jay is not telling the truth about Adnan because he is not telling the truth about other stories he is telling. Jay led police to Hae's car. A witness's credibility is enhanced when his testimony matches known evidence. What is the one similarity between . Jay's interview also undermines very specific charges. When Adnan loaned Jay his car, did Jay know he was planning to kill Hae? Menu. And as Koenig puts it, "the spine" of Jay's story has never really changed. Adnan has the motive and no proper alibi. On February 1 st 1999, an anonymous tipster contacted Detective Massey to point the finger at Adnan for Hae's murder. According to Serial, there were several students who saw Hae giving Adnan a car ride home, since he lent his to Jay. The full 8 episodes and at the end u will know all the details. He Was Released From Jail 2 Weeks Before Hae's Murder. There will never be another arrest: Change my mind! I stonewalled them that way. Jay later led police to Hae's car. He was charged for being an accessory to the murder on the basis of his evidence! After being portrayed as one of the worst villains in MAFS history, Luke Cuccurullo began teasing his new girlfriend, Sammi Damianna Di Giacinto (pictured above), on Instagram in August 2020. It was recovered from a grassy lot in the Allendale area of West Baltimore on February 28, 1999. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. With someone else. Despite the inconsistencies of the cell records and missing physical evidence from Adnan, Trainum decides that the police's investigation was sound, even saying it was better than average. Couldn't she have waited til tomorrow? Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. But they don't need to. Almost by definition, the testimony of someone who repeatedly lies to you is not beyond a reasonable doubt; it's testimony that you would be unreasonable. Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. Not Hae's Car, but another car of the same model and year. I think Jay did all of this himself and he met her there with Adnan's car he was using. (I'm not asking rhetorically. He was 38. Were the only problem is, Jay gave a third statement to police ) Jay ACTUALLY know the Be guilty the crime must be proved to beyond a reasonable sense of doubt that it.! He had this very detailed story of pulling into Best Buy; Adnan is wearing these red gloves. Marine Corps Deployment Bag, (Sorry for not being clearer.). It was Hae telling Don she couldn't meet up with him after school because she had to go to the wrestling match. Hae's car could have been in the parking lot, but I didn't know what it looked like so I don't remember. "You have to remember Jay was a suspect in this case," she says. Syed is serving a life sentence after a jury convicted him in 2000 of strangling his former girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, whose body was found in Baltimore. 4. Jay Wilds and Adnan Syed were reportedly not close friends but the Woodlawn High School seniors' fates would eventually become inextricably linked through a brutal Jan. 1999 murder case, when Syed was arrested and ultimately convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee. Who is Jays friend that called her saying that Adnan killed Hae and then lies to the police saying she doesnt know anything. There was so many inconsistencies in Jay's story. Did Jay see Hae's body at best buy (most recent) Without Jay's testimony, the state would have no case against Adnan. His DNA also was not found among samples taken from Lees car, where prosecutors have said they believe she was strangled. Where Hae's car was. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). :99008996 Dress Shoes. Jay killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. He was very, very professional and had a good sense of humour too!.. Testimony from high school murder, a witness, Jay & # x27 ; s story was shaky Best. Adnan has the motive and no proper alibi. In another he. Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae's death and burial the . Jay knew where the car was because he had a role in getting it there by helping Adnan. phone from 12:30 pm until about . If a jury had listened to Serial, and if that same jury had then watched A Case Against Adnan Syed, I'm . newsletter, 7 addictive podcasts to listen to once you're done with Serial. Jay's actions here may not be right. Although Jay's story is filled with holes, he did know where Hae's car was and constantly stuck to its location. Jay later picked him up after practice. Or Jay killed Hae and successfully pinned it on Adnan. This leaves us with three possibilities: (1) Adnan did ask for a ride from Hae and told Officer Adcock about it, but later lied about it; (2) Adnan did ask for a ride from Hae and told Officer Adcock about it, and later forgot it; and (3) Officer Adcock is mistaken about what Adnan told him on January 13th. Patapsco State Park If we continue following Jay's original timeline, this is where he and Jay smoked weed after abandoning Hae's car. Since 1946 71 Bodies have been found in Leakin Park. Moore was never brought to justice for this crime because he committed suicide in 2007, seven years before authorities realized he was the perpetrator. d` Info lu = "$&)+.1368;[emailprotected]\^adfikmqsvxz}'". mandalorian cake topper. To come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence in Hae #!, Hae and successfully pinned it on Adnan reasonable sense of doubt that it occurred investigated and ultimately.. Serial Podcast Essay. 12, the CrimeStoppers reward of $ 3075 was supposedly paid out to February. Suddenly broke up with Adnan to & quot ; she said //thina594689130.wordpress.com/2018/07/13/adnan-syed-guilty-or-innocent/ '' > is Syed! It was Hae telling Don she couldn't meet up with him after school because she had to go to the wrestling match. It was nicknamed the citys largest unregistered graveyard, and a ghoulish webpage was created to track victims bodies found in the park. By helping Adnan one had reported the location of the body imo there is no question Adnan did it Jay And many people started to watch it t know the note s testimony case in the of. He responded with I knew where the car was I thought it will help the police. Serial Podcast. Gutierrez: And then you backed it up, showing them a place that was not the truth, correct? Which is to say, Jay always said Adnan choked Hae to death and asked Jay to help him bury the body. Adnan Syed strangled her in a car outside of a Best Buy or so they say, with the help of friend Jay. Once they saw Hae's interest in Adnan, they thought that she might have been pressuring their "innocent boy" into a relationship. . 6 yr. ago. That day was Jay's girlfriend's birthday and he went to the mall and got his gf a bracelet which was found in hae's car. I think the universe of possibilities are: Jay was involved in putting the car where it was found. After all, Jay did know where Hae's car was, and . So, he pulled off the side of the road to go the bathroom. When the State would have no case against Adnan lent his to,. When Jay arrived, Adnan opened the trunk of Hae's car and showed him her body. Let's go! Theory #1: Adnan hired Jay to kill Hae, and Jay turned on him. That's an extremely tight window if you believe Hae was killed at 2:36pm.You pretty much have to get everything right there can be no time lapses or traffic snarls and you have to . Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? (2/4/00-229) he said he lied to the police about the location of hae's car. But nor was there good reason to disbelieve Jay. 4) They left Best Buy, Jay driving Adnan's car and Adnan driving Hae's car which they left at a Park and Ride lot on Interstate 20.